They Broke the Law - You Be the Judge by T. Jacobs

Bibliography
Jacobs, T. (2003). They broke the law – you be the judge: True cases of teen crime. Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit Publishing.

212 pages

Plot
In Thomas A. Jacobs' nonfiction book, They Broke the Law, readers are asked to determine sentencing on juveniles who have broken the law. Judge Jacobs offers readers the ability to learn the background of each teen and tween, the actual crime, and mitigating circumstances which could affect the verdict. Readers will learn about teens and tweens committing minor offenses including cutting school, domestic issues such as fighting with family members, and stealing a pregnancy kit to more serious offenses including drug use and violence. Above it all, Jacob allows the reader to witness what actually happened, and be the judge.

Review
Jacob’s nonfiction work is a testament both to his sense of justice as well as his respect for teens’ and tweens’ ability to overcome their mistakes. The novel features just some of his cases throughout his 30 years as a lawyer and a judge. While the format feels more educational in nature, the book is an easy read for those interested in developing a career in the legal profession. Jacob offers readers easy to understand definitions of legal jargon as well as traditional sentencing options that are usually considered appropriate for the various crimes committed. Oftentimes, the results are different from these options, allowing for readers to use their own opinion to justify their thoughts as well as Jacobs'. All in all, the book appears to be a bit dated, but the content is interesting.

Genre
Non Fiction

Reading Level/Interest Level
This book should appeal to readers in 5th – 8th grade.

Similar Content
Thomas A. Jacobs’ Teens on Trial and What Are My Rights?

Personal thoughts
Since this book featured juveniles from age 9 to 17, I felt that it would be appropriate for a tween reader. The book promotes readers to use critical thinking, see things from others’ perspectives, and think in abstract terms. As is true for many people, the mistakes made are oftentimes due to other issues, not just an individual’s desire to do something bad. This book can help tweens think carefully before passing judgment.

Subjects/themes
Juvenile Crime and Punishment
Critical Thinking
Passing Judgment
Legal System

Awards
No known awards.

Series information
No known sequels, although the author has also written Teens on Trial and What Are My Rights?

Character names/descriptions
Not applicable

Annotation
This time Judge Thomas A. Jacobs asks you to pass judgment on your peers.